| UFC 259: Blachowicz vs. Adesanya | Askar Askarov | 1042 →1067(+25) | Joseph Benavidez | 1141 →1115(-26) | Flyweight | Loss | U-DEC |
UFC Fight Night: Figueiredo vs. Benavidez 2 | Deiveson Figueiredo | 1135 →1160(+25) | Joseph Benavidez | 1166 →1141(-25) | Flyweight | Loss | SUB |
| UFC Fight Night: Benavidez vs. Figueiredo | Deiveson Figueiredo | 1107 →1135(+28) | Joseph Benavidez | 1195 →1166(-29) | Flyweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Ngannou vs. Dos Santos | Joseph Benavidez | 1176 →1195(+19) | Jussier Formiga | 1115 →1096(-19) | Flyweight | Win | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Cejudo vs. Dillashaw | Joseph Benavidez | 1161 →1176(+15) | Dustin Ortiz | 1073 →1058(-15) | Flyweight | Win | U-DEC |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Heavy Hitters Finale | Joseph Benavidez | 1143 →1161(+18) | Alex Perez | 1061 →1043(-18) | Flyweight | Win | KO |
| UFC 225: Whittaker vs. Romero 2 | Sergio Pettis | 1066 →1091(+25) | Joseph Benavidez | 1169 →1143(-26) | Flyweight | Loss | S-DEC |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Tournament of Champions Finale | Joseph Benavidez | 1154 →1169(+15) | Henry Cejudo | 1063 →1048(-15) | Flyweight | Win | S-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Hendricks vs Thompson | Joseph Benavidez | 1141 →1154(+13) | Zach Makovsky | 1018 →1005(-13) | Flyweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 192: Cormier vs Gustafsson | Joseph Benavidez | 1125 →1141(+16) | Ali Bagautinov | 1047 →1031(-16) | Flyweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 187: Johnson vs Cormier | Joseph Benavidez | 1107 →1125(+18) | John Moraga | 1067 →1049(-18) | Flyweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Edgar vs Swanson | Joseph Benavidez | 1090 →1107(+17) | Dustin Ortiz | 1042 →1025(-17) | Flyweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 172: Jones vs Teixeira | Joseph Benavidez | 1072 →1090(+18) | Tim Elliott | 1000 →981(-19) | Flyweight | Win | SUB |
| UFC on FOX: Johnson vs. Benavidez 2 | Demetrious Johnson | 1100 →1122(+22) | Joseph Benavidez | 1094 →1072(-22) | Flyweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC Fight Night: Teixeira vs Bader | Joseph Benavidez | 1076 →1094(+18) | Jussier Formiga | 1002 →984(-18) | Flyweight | Win | KO |
| UFC on FOX: Henderson vs Melendez | Joseph Benavidez | 1054 →1076(+22) | Darren Uyenoyama | 1040 →1018(-22) | Flyweight | Win | KO |
| UFC 156: Aldo vs Edgar | Joseph Benavidez | 1038 →1054(+16) | Ian McCall | 981 →964(-17) | Flyweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 152: Jones vs Belfort | Demetrious Johnson | 1037 →1059(+22) | Joseph Benavidez | 1059 →1038(-21) | Flyweight | Loss | S-DEC |
| UFC on FX: Alves vs Kampmann | Joseph Benavidez | 1038 →1059(+21) | Yasuhiro Urushitani | 1000 →979(-21) | Flyweight | Win | KO |
| UFC Live: Hardy vs Lytle | Joseph Benavidez | 1021 →1038(+17) | Eddie Wineland | 980 →962(-18) | Bantamweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 128: Shogun vs Jones | Joseph Benavidez | 1000 →1021(+21) | Ian Loveland | 1020 →998(-22) | Bantamweight | Win | U-DEC |
